In article <3685945f.0 at ns2.wsg.net>, "Ray Scanlon" <rscanlon at wsg.net> writes:
>tonyjeffs wrote:
>>I see no evidence of free will in any human or computer behaviour.
>>I agree as long as we restrict ourselves to the material universe.
I think we're in full agreement here.
>If we
>turn to soul we will come us against free will.
There is one philosophical exception to your final point which interests me .
A passive *non-participant* soul - in the sense of a person watching a movie
in the cinema - does not invite the concept of 'free will'.
Tony